Facemasks Are Not an 'Inconvenience', Facemasks Are Not Trivial: A List of Some of the Underappreciated and Hard-to-Articulate Reasons Forced Masking is so Distressing
Being difficult to articulate does not make the harms and suffering inflicted by facemasks any less real, but does make them more distressing
“Experience has shown that communities faced with epidemics or other adverse events respond best and with the least anxiety when the normal social functioning of the community is least disrupted”
- DA Henderson, Disease Mitigation Measures in the Control of Pandemic Influenza, 2006
One of the most trenchant arguments made by proponents of forced masking is some variation of “it’s just an inconvenience”, so/and/or “why do you have to make such a big deal about it”. (To be clear, this is not a legitimate scientific or factual argument for the adoption of any policy, but that is not what this article is about.) I am largely going to avoid the issues unique to masking children - what is plainly institutionalized child abuse - and for people with disabilities or past trauma, as many of the harms inflicted by masks are readily apparent and easily articulable.
On the surface, this contention seems like a morally and factually compelling argument. After all, if masks had any meaningful efficacy, wouldn’t it be a worthwhile tradeoff to endure a little discomfort to reduce the far worse suffering and death that would otherwise be inflicted by covid?
Yet this argument - “what’s the big deal” - does not square with how many people experience masks and mask mandates, including practically everyone who disagrees with masking as a policy. It is undeniable that millions of people are considerably more tormented by facemasks than what we would expect is reasonable or even possible for something that is indeed merely an “inconvenience”. People generally do not profoundly suffer from trivialities.
In other words, clearly facemasks are a considerably greater burden for many people than how they superficially appear; and yet few people are able to work out for themselves what about them is so abusive or terrible. The goal of this article is to enumerate some of the myriad harms and emotional abuses inflicted by forced masking, specifically those that are difficult to articulate or identify the connection to masking.
So what exactly is the big deal about wearing masks?
In a nutshell - as was just stated - mask wearing is to many people something that is enormously stressful, and something that evokes inordinately powerful negative emotions. This is simply the reality, irrespective of whether such feelings “make sense”.
Now, as a general rule, if someone feels powerfully about something, there’s a reason; or in other words, there is something that is provoking the strong emotions. And the source of these feelings does not have to be the thing that the feelings attach to. The only thing that matters is that the feelings exist, however misguided they may be.
This is not to say that the reality of feelings should be the dominant consideration above everything else. The current radical ‘social justice’ movement that has elevated one’s subjective “identity” as the defining characteristic of a person is the Reductio ad Absurdum of enshrining subjective feelings in place of objective reality itself.
What is true however is that the emotional distress and suffering of people is quite real. So even if you happen to be in favor of mask mandates and not at all bothered by mask wearing, that does not make the profoundly distressing experience of someone else any less real of an experience.
The following list is not exhaustive, just a collection of some of the factors that make mask wearing, especially forced masking, so distressing to many people.
A few important things to keep in mind:
Not every listed issue is true for every person who finds masks distressing.
Each issue amplifies the other ones, so that the cumulative distress is far greater than the sum of its parts. It’s like the difference between 1+2+3+…10 and 1x2x3x…10 (55 vs 3,628,800).
This list is not exhaustive.
The short explanations are intended to give a bit more insight into how people might typically experience that particular stress. They are not intended to comprehensively define the issue.
Emotional Stresses of Mask Mandates
Deprivation of Personal Autonomy
Depriving someone of their personal autonomy is stressful and demeaning. This is amplified when it is about something that is emotionally fraught, subject to strong opinions and feelings, relates to morality/values, and/or is something that has an implication that you lack the capacity to look out for your own interest. Free will is a defining trait of being human, and the abrogation thereof is experienced as an assault on ones individuality/sense of self/fundamental autonomy.
A Sense of Helplessness
Being at the mercy of the arbitrary and capricious whims of others makes you feel a sense of helplessness, which is extremely stressful and grueling, and can eventually break a person mentally and emotionally (and is therefore a favored tactic used by tyrants to break the will of the population so that they are too broken to revolt (see Stalin’s reign of terror)).
Invalidating Your Personal Identity
Masking is now - regardless of the factual merits - a political symbol in society. Being forced to mask is by definition being forced to yield in ones own actions - and worse, in ones public appearance - to your ideological and/or political opposition. Imagine if the government decided to make wearing a religious skullcap mandatory for everyone - you can make the same argument that is being made for masking - what’s the big deal, you barely notice it, etc - I am quite confident that atheists for instance would would feel very keenly the assault on their personal identity.
Assaulting Your Sense of Morality / Making You Feel Like You’re Immoral and Selfish
Mask mandates force people opposed to masking to internalize that they are acting immorally and selfishly for two reasons. The first is that society is enshrining into law that how you act is immoral and selfish, which is a public declaration to the world that you are immoral and selfish. The second is that how you act outwardly always exerts influence in how you feel and identify internally, so constantly wearing a mask eats away at your internal convictions - even if you can withstand this, it creates some degree of cognitive dissonance internally. No one likes to feel like they are evil or selfish.
Deprives / Ruins Human Interactions
The quality and nature of social interactions is greatly reduced & damaged. Every interaction behind masks is fundamentally different. Interacting in this way can feel sad, despondent, isolating, cold, and/or cruel, among other things. Multiplied over thousands, then tens or even hundreds of thousands of little interactions is being repeatedly bludgeoned with little ‘pebbles’ of sadness/isolation/coldness/cruelty - a profoundly disturbing and distressing experience.
Over Time Changes Your Personality
Facemasks are a radical and unnatural impingement on normal mental and emotional functioning. Over time, this can change your personality - such as making you less social, less outgoing, more suspicious, decreased tendency or desire to be kind and so on.
Turns Other People Into Abusive Tyrants
This is meant to capture the phenomenon of a subset of people who have turned into cruel and vicious individuals and abuse people whom they have power over - such as people who genuinely derive pleasure from imposing their will upon others through force.
A General Feeling of Being Trapped in a Nightmare
Many people feel a clear and distinct sense of being trapped in some sort of perverse nightmare as a result of covid policies, especially masking which is the most prominent and visible manifestation of these policies, which is an extremely distressing experience, especially when it feels like there is no end in sight.
Elementary Lack of Fairness
People are very sensitive to fairness, and can feel enormous stress and distress when treated unfairly, especially when the unfair treatment is egregious. Mask policies are literally imposing on some people so other people can feel safer - a grotesquely unequal treatment, that in order to help the emotional health of the scared-to-death-of-covid pro-maskers, everyone else’s mental & emotional health will be trampled on by forced masking. Moreover, mask mandates preferentially enshrines the political, moral, and ideological views and sensibilities of one segment of society without any justification or regard that they actually be morally or politically sensible.
Repeated Experience of “Losing” in Public Policy Decisions
The experience of losing again, and again, and again in substantial, significant public policy decisions is itself very distressing. This happens to be one of the more prominent animating forces that drove Trump’s voter base - that they felt they always lost again and again and again and again no matter the issue. Covid policy for a substantial portion of the population has been a series of devastating losses as practically every policy choice cuts against them viciously. (And they are constantly demonized for daring to even voice their opposition.)
Feeling That Other People Matter While I Don’t
This is a distinct distress in addition to the lack of fairness - that “I don’t matter”; this is amplified considerably when “other people matter”. This is what people who are systematically disregarded tend to feel, and it is very painful. People opposed to mask wearing are not only disregarded as a practical matter by policies such as forced masking, the practically unanimous voice of the media & both political parties unrelentingly is constantly saying how such people genuinely do not matter at all.
And this is especially pronounced in racial minorities who already feel this way from previous history -- mostly white liberal elites are forcing their preferences on blacks and other minorities.
The Stress of Difficulty Communicating
The frustration that comes from difficulty communicating is underappreciated, and tends to leave people feeling annoyed, frustrated and stressed.
The Damage From Failed Communication
This particular harm also has another, more tangible dimension - often, people having a hard time communicating simply give up, and giving up is itself an added stress factor that leaves people frazzled. Furthermore, if for instance you’re talking to your doctor and you “give up” instead of making sure you understood what he was trying to tell you - especially older people who psychologically tend to both give up faster and innately have more physical difficulty hearing to begin with - that could be a big problem.
The Distress of Constant Harassment
Mask mandates are a constant intrusion into people’s personal lives that leaves people feeling exasperated - “just leave me alone already” / “just let me live in peace”. It is a basic human need to not be constantly harassed by others.
Living In Constant State of Worry, Fear, and Anger
Knowing that you have to submit to the mask mandates in many places where you need to go leaves you always feeling a variety of negative and unhealthy emotions about it. In other words, it is a basket of negative emotions always softly purring in the background of your consciousness, and oftentimes not in the background but at the forefront of your mind.
Saps the Joy From Many Different Activities
Take shopping, for instance. For many people, shopping is a leisure activity that can be an effective emotional detox from life stresses… but not when you have to wear a mask to do it. In addition to the stress that is the frustration of having your little good things in life stolen from you, there is also the stress & emotional unhealthiness that comes from losing the benefits of the “small pleasures” that are a crucial detox from the rough dimensions of daily life for people.
Living In Perpetual Stress/Fear From Social Enforcers
Inevitably, people opposed to mask mandates will not be particularly zealous about following them to a “T”, whether it be letting the mask slide down your face, taking it off for a few minutes here and there, or just munching on a bag of peanuts for 3 hours. There is always a baseline stress of constantly having to be alert for the “mask police” (whether they are actual police or just really annoying screeching Karens).
The aforementioned “mask police” are often extremely zealous - unhinged, really - a cursory trip through social media readily testifies that a non-masking-compliant person getting dressed down in public is a common occurrence. Public humiliation can be a deeply painful & traumatic experience, especially if immortalized in a viral social media clip.
Mask mandates leave many people feeling emotionally abused. This is both from the masking being forced upon people despite all the mental and emotional distress it causes - in other words, abuse - and from the constant manipulation that is characteristic of abusers that is part and parcel of mask mandates.
Plain & Simple Bullying
Mask mandates are forced coercion jammed down the throats of those who strongly resent them. This is vicious bullying. No one enjoys feeling bullied, or having someone else’s will imposed on them against their own will.
The Distress of Being Under the Control of Someone You Loathe
Think of it this way: Imagine two ppl vying for the same promotion who hate each others guts, and then the winner is made the boss of the loser. This is an added, separate affront to the loser. Same idea here - the anti- mask people are being specifically dictated to by the very opponents they despise, and on the very issue that they’re fighting over. This isn’t just at a national level - this is probably more true about local county or school board fights, and this is a reliable recipe for bad blood and lasting enmity to boot.
The “Tax” of Buying Masks that are Less Unpleasant
Many people choose to buy fancier masks than the nasty surgical masks widely available everywhere for free, because they are far less unpleasant (and far more sanitary and subject to [more] manufacturing standards and quality control). This itself is a further indignity - if the government wants to impose a draconian mandate on us, the least the government can do is to make comfortable masks available, especially considering the government is throwing cash everywhere because of covid - it’s an added insult and disrespecting of the people being imposed upon, in the sense that it’s just plain coldhearted to act this way to someone else, at least have a little sensitivity and try to make your own mandates as tolerable as possible on the people you’re imposing on.
Irrational Government Actions Breed A Sense of Fear and Instability
Watching the government act in such a factually irrational manner is itself very stressful to many people, as is living under an irrational regime. One’s sense of stability and trust in the world is rooted by necessity in the belief that common moral sense/rationality is a limiting principle at some point upon what government and people/institutions with power in society are able and willing to do.
Makes People Doubt Their Sense of Reality
The very fact of making a crazy policy is itself deeply destructive to people’s sense of reality. In other words, there is tremendous cognitive dissonance of on the one hand knowing that masking is nuts, but on the other hand, watching the government make mask mandates - it is very hard to have a genuine emotional conviction that essentially the entire medical community and all of society’s institutions have gone stark raving mad. Such cognitive dissonance is very damaging psychologically to your sense of self and your sense of reality, and is also mentally and emotionally exhausting.
Destroys People’s Sense of Trust & Stability
Being forced to do irrational and insane things erodes a person’s sense of confidence that there is a baseline rationality in society (in addition to the erosion that comes from witnessing the government & other institutions that wield power over society lacking any rationality mentioned above) -- something that provides people with a sense of stability and security in life generally. It is distressing to feel like there is absolutely no rational limiting principle on government actions or policies, since this by definition means that there is nothing that you can trust is sacred and beyond government (or someone else) coming and destroying. (This also actively erodes the social fabric that relies upon the general presumption of the average person being rational.)
Destructive of People’s Humanity and Dignity
Being forced to act irrationally causes you to lose your sense of dignity as a human being with an intellectual faculty that distinguishes man from animals. In other words, the more you are suppressed from acting in accordance with intelligence, the less you feel the unique transcendence of being a human being - treating people like animals makes them feel like animals.
Dehumanization Through Forced Anonymity
Your face is the most visibly manifest characteristic that sets you apart as a unique individual. Masks, by covering your face, strip you to some degree of your sense of being a unique individual and instead makes you feel more like a number than a person. It also distorts your sense of the humanity of others, as you inevitably become trained to perceive other people as lacking human-ness.
They’re so Darn Uncomfortable
Masks can be extremely uncomfortable to wear, especially for long stretches at a time. They can also be quite gross to wear - if you sneeze into the mask, well……
Pragmatic Harms of Mask Mandates
Promotes Authoritarianism and Fascism
This is true as written - the ascendance of authoritarian and tyrannical governance has been as shocking as it was swift. Mask mandates - which are objectively draconian and authoritarian regardless of whether they are scientifically warranted - internalize in people that authoritarian governance is normal, acceptable, and not evil. This is a problem. Every genocidal regime started this way - cite an emergency that justifies draconian governmental powers that people would otherwise reject as tyrannical and evil. This by itself is sufficient justification to fight mask mandates “to the death” - to preserve the democratic society and social compact.
On a more relatable level, mask mandates accustom government officials to acting like tyrants, and enjoying their newfound dictatorial powers, a ‘perk’ they are very unlikely to part with willingly.
Promotes Religious Cultism
Masks have become a religious symbol of virtuosity of a fanatical cult of irrational beliefs, a cult whose members have completely forsaken thinking (even non-critical thinking, like lone drivers wearing masks in their cars). Cults have committed some of the most horrific and bizarre atrocities over the past century.
Socially Conditions the Citizenry to Be Docile and Unthinking
Authoritarian mandates that are based only upon the word of people (the “experts”), especially in stark contradiction to facts and common sense, conditions people to be docile, and to not think about anything (as their intellects and opinions are scorned and said to be of too poor quality to be legitimate sources of knowledge for anyone, including themselves). This destroys the vibrancy and energy of the society, and conditions people to not think of themselves as individually capable beings who have the potential to achieve using their own innate abilities and intellect, a critical driving force necessary to impel people to make something of themselves.
Mask mandates help to further sow division and enmity between the factions of society by oppressing one faction while also giving the other faction the moral grounds to claim that the anti-mask faction by not going along with the mandate policies are in violation of the law, and are acting immorally as defined by societal approbation of mask mandates as a crucial health measure.
All-Encompassing Harms of Mask Mandates
The most obvious general harm of mask mandates is stress. Stress is known to be aggressively destructive to your health, and something that significantly exacerbates practically every known medical condition. Everything listed above causes the people afflicted to be generally stressed.
Breach of the Social Compact
When part of society is so wantonly destructive towards another part of society, the society loses its legitimacy in the eyes of the oppressed, and the rule of law is incorrigibly eroded, since one side simply inflicts their will upon the other side regardless of the laws, conventions, and norms of society; and without any limiting principle. “Rule of law for thee but not for me” is not rule of law, and has no moral legitimacy for the “thee” to respect or comply.
Indefinite Nature of the Suffering
The indefinite-ness of the situation is itself a source of considerable suffering, or a powerful amplification of the suffering one is already experiencing. It is infinitely easier and more bearable to handle suffering that you can see its end, when it will pass, versus suffering that seems inescapable and endless. (The feeling that their suffering is inescapable/endless is a ubiquitous factor that leads people to commit suicide.)
C’mon, most of these are silly?
The ultimate refuge of someone trapped by the facts is scorn and mockery. Human nature drives a person to feel and act derisive about something that requires depth to grasp, especially something that they have a reason to want to not be true. Human nature also strongly tends towards not just denying but mocking anything that challenges the morality and prudence of your opinions and actions. Thus people are told that their experiences and suffering from mask mandates is not real and makes no sense - one of the most insidious and abhorrent forms of abusive manipulation.
It is therefore very difficult to gain an appreciation and understanding of most of the things on this list. On the other hand, it is far easier to destroy any sense of comprehension and emotional awareness of these - all that is necessary is one pithy line scorning this whole notion as delusional. Such is the power of mockery, that one witty zinger can completely vanquish the awareness gained from many hours of thoughtfulness and introspection.
So no, these are not silly, and feeling these does not make you a baby. This accusation is nothing more than the panicked derision that is the last defense of someone who can’t debate the actual facts.
The Manipulative Nature of an Abusive Relationship
One of the textbook tactics utilized by abusers to maintain control in an abusive relationship is to define the context and facts of anything related to the relationship so as to get in the victim’s head so to speak and distort their sense of reality so that they are unable to articulate - even to themselves - the fact of their abuse and victimization.
As we all can see, the constant claims of “facemasks are not a big deal”, “there’s no conceivable reason for anyone to think that masks can be harmful”, etc, accomplished this quite effectively. The goal of this article was to unwind this pernicious and abusive lie in order to re-empower victims of forced masking against the proponents of mask policies who are abusive and manipulative. (Sometimes mask policies are reluctantly put in place in order to accommodate political or legal realities where masking is the least destructive option.)
This can be summed up as one more type of emotional distress inflicted by mask mandate proponents:
The contention that “facemasks are just an inconvenience” amounts to abusive manipulation that steals the ability of the victims of forced masking to identify and articulate the suffering and harm they experience from forced mask wearing.
To conclude, the quote at the top of this article from DA Henderson - widely credited with the eradication of smallpox - is very revealing:
“Experience has shown that communities faced with epidemics or other adverse events respond best and with the least anxiety when the normal social functioning of the community is least disrupted”
It is hard to imagine a greater disruption to normal living than the highly visible and symbolic masks ubiquitously worn everywhere.
More than 150 Comparative Studies and Articles on Mask Ineffectiveness and Harms ⋆ Brownstone Institute
Anyone come up with more examples that I missed please feel free to comment.
I want to add a postscript here:
After this article was posted, and especially after it was republished in Brownstone, I was deluged by a flood of emails from people all around the world, written by people from every conceivable walk of life and political affiliation, testifying how their own personal experiences and feelings were captured by this article. I can think of no greater testament to the truth and accuracy of the contention that mask mandates are not trivial or inconsequential in the slightest.
I would only add that (1) for people who speak English (or whatever the local language is) as a second language, masks can completely prevent communication, because it's hard enough to understand without having the person you are talking to muzzled; and (2) for those of us who have experienced sexual assault, the experience of having a hand-sized mask forced onto our faces can provide an extra level of trauma, as it can bring back terrible memories.
I have the misfortune of living in France, a culture completely without empathy. There is no way in hell I would ever tell anybody in my real life why I am having so many panic attacks at the grocery store. I pretty much don't go anywhere in public anymore (the grocery store is only for things I run out of between "big shops" at the Internet-based grocery store where I drive in and they just put my things in the car), and I have grown to hate my country.
Did I miss it? The most important aspect of masking IMO is class segregation: that's why slaves were masked.
In all resorts and high end restaurants and events (Hollywood comes to mind) the serving class is masked while customers aren't . It's immediately obvious. Your status as superior or inferior is stated. Degrading of the underlings is done to elevate the masters.
That's the whole point of military grades on display or uniforms as well.
That's the nature and pricing power of brands too.
To belong..to the master class.
Or rather...to humiliate physically and mentally the serving class.
Another purpose is to be found in hypnosis induction: when done properly it is incremental and illogical. You wear it when told. Even better when not needed. Even better when the command is specific (make sure your nose is covered). The inductee then is on a slippery slope of docility and trance induction. To deeper levels of compliance. Until total mental control.
Until she herself becomes the enforcer of the crazy rules. It works beautifully. Sadly.